A Rarely Seen Caravaggio Masterpiece Makes Its Way to Florida
A rarely seen work by the great Italian artist Caravaggio (1571–1610), the master of chiaroscuro who helped usher the Renaissance into the Baroque period, is coming to Florida for an exhibition at the Museum of Fine Arts, St. Petersburg. The canvas, titled Boy Bitten by a Lizard, is the star of a show featuring 40 paintings by the Caravaggisti, as the renowned artist’s followers have come to be known.
“It’s really fascinating to see the enormous impact of this single revolutionary artist,” Stanton Thomas, the MFA St. Petersburg’s chief curator, told me.
Titled “In Caravaggio’s Light: Baroque Masterpieces from the Fondazione Roberto Longhi,” the exhibition is drawn from the holdings of the Fondazione Roberto Longhi, an institute founded in 1970 by Italian art historian Roberto Longhi (1889–1970). A leading Caravaggio scholar, Longhi is credited with rehabilitating the artist’s reputation after a long period during which Baroque art was decidedly out of fashion. Flying in the face of popular opinion, Longhi recognized the power of Caravaggio’s dramatically lit images, with all of the emotion and psychological intensity bound up in the realism of his canvases.
“During the 19th century, and even before that, Baroque painting was seen as overdramatic and in poor taste,” Thomas said. “And with Caravaggio, who was so peripatetic and just not very well understood or documented up until that point, Longhi recognized the quality of the paintings. And then he was able to do the archival research to discover more about Caravaggio’s life, and also to reattribute things to Caravaggio himself. So he’s really the person who single-handedly revived the career of this extraordinarily influential artist.”
Valentin De Boulogne, Denial of Saint Peter (ca. 1615–17). Courtesy of Fondazione di Studi di Storia dell’Arte Roberto Longhi, Florence, Italy.
An Art Historian Who Collected What He Studied
While Longhi was helping restore Caravaggio’s rightful place in the pantheon of art historical greats, he and his wife, fellow art historian Anna Banti, were also buying forgotten masterpieces of the era. Their collection is technically open to the public at the foundation’s Florence headquarters, where it can be visited by appointment, but has remained largely unseen by American audiences.
The last time Boy Bitten by a Lizard was in the U.S. was in 2012, at Fort Worth’s Kimbell Art Museum. Before that, it was 1940. And the larger Longhi collection has never had a dedicated outing in this country. (The show previously traveled to Poland and France, but this is its first time off the continent.)
Caravaggio, Boy Bitten by a Lizard (1593–94). Collection of the Fondazione Roberto Longhi, Florence.
There is another autograph version of the work at London’s National Gallery, but this is a rare opportunity for American audiences to see the dramatic composition without taking a Transatlantic flight.
“We’ve all had that moment where something really uncomfortable suddenly happened to us.
It’s an amazing gesture—the young man is pulling his shoulders back and recoiling, with this look of shock and pain on his face. And it’s so true to life. I think that it still compels people to look at it centuries later because it is so realistic,” Thomas said. “Enhancing that is that beautiful light, the figure emerging from the shadowy recesses, this wonderful contrast between the shadows and the very pale skin. And then you get an even greater sense of luminosity because of that wonderful little still life where the lizard’s been hiding and the extraordinary vase.”
The MFA St. Petersburg exhibition will actually feature at least two original Caravaggio paintings, with Boy Bitten by a Lizard being joined by two copies of Boy Peeling Fruit, an early composition by the artist that he is believed to have painted multiple times while training in the workshop of artist Giuseppe Cesari (1568–1640). (Earlier this year, a Baroque art expert claimed to have found the earliest known version of the work, and by extension, the first known painting by Caravaggio.)
At the MFA, one will be on loan from a private collection in Rome, and the other is from Longhi’s collection—when he originally bought it, the art historian thought it was an autograph Caravaggio, but he later identified it as a copy. The foundation stands by that opinion, but it is more generally accepted as the real deal.
“Our understanding of Caravaggio has evolved since then, thanks to new technical examinations and better understanding of the artist and his career. One of the most exciting things about this exhibition is the chance to compare two versions,” said Thomas, who strongly suspects Longhi might have been right the first time. “I’m billing the show as two-and-a-half Caravaggios!”
Caravaggio, Boy Peeling Fruit (ca. 1593). Opinions vary on whether this work is an original or a copy. Courtesy of Fondazione di Studi di Storia dell’Arte Roberto Longhi, Florence, Italy.
Why Is Caravaggio So Important?
Today, Caravaggio is one of art history’s biggest names, with any potential discovery of a new work by the artist making headlines around the world. Earlier this year, a blockbuster exhibition in Rome, “Caravaggio 2025,” brought together 24 examples of his work, and had to extend its run to meet audience demand.
An authenticated Caravaggio has not hit the auction block in modern times, according to the Artnet Price Database—although a purported rediscovered second version of his Judith Beheading Holofernes was snapped up by a private buyer ahead of a planned 2019 auction where it was expected to fetch up to €150 million ($171 million).
Another painting, originally attributed to a follower of another Baroque artist, was set to be auctioned in Spain in April 2021, until it was identified as a Caravaggio. The work, Ecce homo (1604–05), subsequently went on view at the Museo del Prado Museum in Madrid and sold last year to a British collector for €36 million ($39 million).
“In many ways, I see Caravaggio as the Baroque spirit,” Thomas said. “He’s the first person to really look to the street to find models who were from the lower classes. They were prostitutes and beggars, and that gives us sudden realism to his work. And of course, there’s the tenebrism. There’s that incredible lighting, as if a flashbulb on an old-fashioned camera went off. All of a sudden you see these wonderful shadows with these faces, these gestures emerging from the darkness. And this was something that people hadn’t seen before.”
Carlo Saraceni, Judith with the Head of Holofernes (ca. 1615–20). Courtesy of Fondazione di Studi di Storia dell’Arte Roberto Longhi, Florence, Italy.
An Artist Who Inspired Many Who Followed
We only know of one artist who studied formally under Caravaggio, a mysterious painter known as Cecco del Caravaggio. But because so many of Caravaggio’s works were public commissions, in some of Rome and Naples’s most important churches, his work became widely influential.
“One of the things that’s fascinating about the Caravaggisti is that it wasn’t just people in Rome and Naples.
Artists were traveling to Rome from all over Western Europe, particularly the low countries, both Holland and Belgium, but also France, as well as Spain. And they would come and see Caravaggio, and then they would travel back to their own countries and spread [his influence] further,” Thomas said.
That dissemination across Europe is clearly illustrated in the exhibition. From Caravaggio’s native Italy, there is Carlo Saraceni’s Judith with the Head of Holofernes, from about 1610 to 1620. From the Netherlands, there are a pair of dramatic religious scenes by Matthias Stomer (ca. 1600–after 1652). And from France, there is Valentin de Boulogne’s (1591–1632) The Denial of Saint Peter, from about 1620.
“It shows that moment just a few hours after Christ has been arrested and Peter is shaken and he denies him. It’s this amazing image of accusation and self-doubt,” Thomas said.
Jusepe Ribera, San Bartolomeo (1613). Collection of the Fondazione Roberto Longhi, Florence.
The show also features five paintings of the apostles from a series by the Spanish painter Jusepe de Ribera (1591–1652) that Thomas called “shockingly contemporary in their directness, in their realism, and in their absolutely profound emotional content.”
Particularly striking is his depiction of Saint Bartholomew (San Bartolomeo), from about 1613. De Ribera has painted the apostle and martyr, who was flayed alive, as an old man holding up his skin, with his face clearly shown.
“In the other hand, he holds a hunter’s knife. And it’s a very specific type of knife, which shows that Ribera did his homework,” Thomas said. “And the saint has this extraordinary look on his face, looking directly out at the viewer. It looks much more like a portrait than an image that would be used for worship. It’s one of the most profound, gritty, modern things that I’ve seen that belongs to the Baroque. It’s extraordinary.”
Reza Aramesh, Study of the Head as Cultural Artefacts (2023). Private collection. Photo: courtesy of the artist and Datan Gallery.
Thomas has also organized a companion exhibition, “Baroque Continuum,” that illustrates how that influence has continued throughout the centuries to the present day. Among the artists featured is contemporary Iranian sculptor Reza Aramesh (b. 1970), who makes classically inspired works in bronze and marble.
“The three pieces by Reza I’ve borrowed are severed heads, and they look like martyred Roman Catholic saints from 1600,” Thomas said. “They’re unbelievably beautiful and powerful and go great with an exhibition which features Judith and the Head of Holofernes. It ties in very nicely to further illuminate how Caravaggio impacted the history of art and continues to do so today.”
“In Caravaggio’s Light: Baroque Masterpieces from the Fondazione Roberto Longhi” will be on view at the Museum of Fine Arts, St. Petersburg, 255 Beach Drive NE, St. Petersburg, Florida, October 25, 2025–March 22, 2026.
“Baroque Continuum” will be on view at the Museum of Fine Arts, St. Petersburg, 255 Beach Drive NE, St. Petersburg, Florida, October 18, 2025–March 22, 2026 More