Seidler’s first apartment complex receives NSW heritage register listing
The NSW government has announced the addition of Australian architect Harry Seidler’s Ithaca Gardens complex in Elizabeth Bay, Sydney, to the state’s heritage register. The first apartment building to be designed by Seidler, Ithaca Gardens is described the government as “one of the finest and best-preserved examples of modernist building design.”
Completed in 1960, the 10-storey building marked the start of Seidler’s professional relationship with developer Jozef Dusseldorf, who in 1951 founded Civil and Civic, a construction company that was acquired by Lendlease a decade later.
According to the government’s communique, “This partnership produced some of the most iconic structures in NSW, demonstrating the pair’s collaborative approach to innovative design outcomes.”
Located at 12 Ithaca Road, Ithaca Gardens is one of the earliest modernist apartments in NSW and is situated among a number of Seidler-designed apartment complexes in Sydney’s eastern suburbs including International Lodge (1970), Ercildoune (1966) and Aquarius (1966), as well as numerous notable developments from other architects.
Debates around the heritage status of these buildings have been ongoing for several years. According to a 2021 article in The Sydney Morning Herald (SMH), the City of Sydney classified “Seidler’s unit blocks as detracting from the heritage precincts around Potts Point and Elizabeth Bay in Sydney’s inner east because they’re only 50 to 60 years old.”
The government’s communique notes that the Ithaca Gardens complex “demonstrated a change in the architectural landscape that went on to drive new trends in the 1960s. The design harnessed principles developed in single residential dwellings and office buildings, and applied these to high-density living.”
View gallery
An article in The SMH reported last year that the council had decided to pursue heritage protections for nine unit buildings, despite facing backlash from owners of Seidler’s Ithaca Gardens. Residents and owners expressed concerns that the protections would make it challenging to proceed with necessary upgrades to their units.
At the time, the Ithaca Gardens owners’ corporation chair Jim Carroll told The SMH, “Ithaca Gardens is not a museum, a place of worship, an office tower or an individual residence – it is home to more than 60 people.”
“Owners […] love and respect the building,” Carroll said, but “want to retain flexibility to meet the[ir] needs and expectations […] while retaining the design integrity of Ithaca Gardens, as we’ve [the owners’ corporation] done for 65 years without the need for heritage listing.”
The complex, which won the Architecture and Arts Award the year it was completed, is described by writer Lucy Moloney as one of Seidler’s “pioneering medium-rise projects […] which introduced European apartment design characteristics to encourage light and cross-breezes from either side.”
In addition, the building is distinguished by the NSW government for its “creative use of concrete to provide function and emulate art, as demonstrated in the folded concrete canopy and garage structure.” Blond brick, aluminum window frames, railings and awnings, and internal coloured glass and timber cabinetry also feature.
View gallery
NSW Minister for Heritage Penny Sharpe commented, “Ithaca Gardens holds huge cultural and historical significance, showcasing Harry Seidler’s evolution as an architect and his lasting impact on Sydney and other parts of NSW.”
“It is an early example of ‘density done well’ and shows some of the earliest Australian examples of outstanding apartment living,” Sharpe said.
Echoing these sentiments, architect and wife of Harry Seidler Penelope Seidler recalled fond memories living within Ithaca Gardens at a celebration of the one hundredth issue of Houses magazine.
“We moved to Ithaca Gardens which was the first major apartment building that Harry built in Elizabeth Bay and we lived there for seven years, and I just loved it, I just loved being in an apartment,” she said.
The government’s release notes that Heritage NSW has worked closely with property owners to tailor the heritage listing, allowing site-specific exemptions to ensure regular works such as individual apartment renovations can go ahead without specific heritage approvals.
Sharpe noted, “Adding Ithaca Gardens to the State Heritage Register will recognise and preserve this architectural gem for generations to come.” More